List of Shows


Tell your friends

TELL YOUR FRIENDS

As the World Turns - NEWS ROOM

In our 'As The World Turns' News Room, Soaps.com keeps you up-to-date with the latest Soap Opera news on the net. We also feature interviews with the soap stars, as well as local appearances by the actors and actresses.

Is ATWT's Lily Really Over Holden?

Wednesday, August 13 2008


Can Lily move on with Mike? (Soaps.com)
Their romance has been on-again, off-again for the past 20 years (or maybe a little bit longer) but As The World Turns' Lily and Holden are still as big of fan favorites now as they were when they were teens. Now, though, it seems that the Lily/Holden romance has finally hit the skids - thanks to a bit of infidelity between Carly and Holden.

When Lily left town last winter to find herself after Dusty's death, Holden had no one to talk to. He had no one to talk to since Jack was embroiled in his own drama with Katie and Brad; a relationship between Carly, who was also lost and lonely without Lily around, was bound to happen. For Carly, it seemed to happen faster. She latched on to Holden's friendship as if it was an anchor. Holden, whose bit of a romance with Bonnie was over, latched on to her, too. Soon the two were inseparable but still fighting their feelings and trying to remain friends only. All of that changed one night at summer camp. Carly and Holden were thrown into the same bunk and their feelings came to a head. They made love but both regretted the decision.

That, of course, didn't stop them from making love again when Holden, jealous over a friendship between Carly and Neal, followed her to New York. At this point, Holden realized how deceitful he was being and told Lily the truth. Enraged, she threw him out and has been trying to move on ever since.

Late last week, Lily made a move on Mike, who gently rebuffed her. He said he wanted to be her friend - and only her friend. Jealous Holden could stand the thought of even a friendship between them and asked Carly (of course!) to intervene. Carly went to Mike, since Lily won't even look at her, and asked him what was going on. Mike insisted he was only friends with Lily and that they would only be friends.

***Spoiler Alert***

This week, however, things are going to change - at least a little bit - for both Lily and Mike. Still trying to get over Holden and angry to learn that he has moved from the farm and into The Lakeview (Lily's hotel of all places!), she turns to Mike. He has been thinking over their flirtation from last week and decides that friendship isn't enough. However, Mike wants to go slow. Lily doesn't want a slow and sweet romance and manages to seduce him; they make love.

Lily still isn't over Holden, though, and is still struggling with what she wants for her life. Holden has been bludgeoning her with the "stay together for the kids" argument and so has Emma. So, to some extent, has Luke! Lily isn't sure what to do but she knows one thing: she wants to be in love with her husband and she wants him to be in love with her. Staying together for the kids is not the kind of life Lily wants and she knows in her heart of hearts that it won't be good for any of the children.

The question is, should she stay with Holden, who can't make up his mind between Lily and Carly? Should she try to move on with Mike? Is Lily really over Holden? Can either of them ever be over the other with the history they have shared?

Some would say no. She will never be truly over Holden and he will never truly be over her. Can they come back from their past this time around? Whatever happens, it is sure to entail a lot of great daytime drama and we will enjoy the ride!


email PRINTABLE VERSION - View a printer friendly version of this article

Please register and login to be able to email this article to your friends

USER COMMENTS

Posted by Blesseddiva at Wednesday, August 13 2008 07:07 AM

I disagree with you. I think sometimes people have to learn to say when. I think Lily will always love Holden and vice versa, but it doesn't mean that they will always be IN love.
Problem 1: Sometimes people mistake nostalgia for current feelings.
It is like running into your high school sweetheart and you start reminiscing about the past. Many people ending up hooking up with that ex just from stirring up "old feelings", but that isn't not enough in the present. Holding on to what isn't there anymore cannot sustain any relationship.

Problem 2: Too many affairs, plus Lily is so wish-washy. I think she just needs to go see about living on her own for a year or two. She is not clear on what she wants anymore. Besides, I really liked her with Dusty (but then again, I liked Holden with Molly too).

Problem 3: Re-casting actors disturbs chemistry.
The new Lily is just beautiful...but lacks that explosive chemistry that Martha Byrne had with Jon Hensley. So that "fire" is not evident with the two of them.
Carly has that fire with both Jack and Holden. In fact, the scenes with Carly and Holden just HOT, HOT, HOT.

So I vote for Holden and Carly to proceed. I think Happiness can be so fleeting. Grab onto it when you find it. Jack's standards are just too high for Carly and Holden has been worned down just enough by Lily. Carly and Holden are in the same zone and timing is everything.

Sorry recast Lily, but you don't sizzle with Holden. It seems too contrive.

Posted by sexydan at Wednesday, August 13 2008 11:59 AM

I don't like the new Lilly. No chemistry with Holden. I'm a huge fan of Holden & Lilly! I watch these characters grow up over the years. But letting Martha go was a huge mistake cause i don't care who you have as lilly it will never be the same. besides i have no idea what Lilly's problem is . Holden slept with Carly but remind me why she left in the first place? Oh that's right to get over Dusty! So she has no right to be angry with him.

Posted by Keela at Wednesday, August 13 2008 06:39 PM

It really pains me that Martha Byrne is gone. I still haven't found any acceptance of current Faux-Lilly. I grew up with Martha's Lilly and she is the only person who I will root for with Holden.
I have resolved that Lilly & Holden are history. I feel nothing for current Faux-Lilly. Due to the circumstances, I adore Holden and Carly.

Posted by Chrissi at Friday, August 15 2008 01:02 PM

I liked the old Lily a lot and I do like the new one. I don't see chemistry but then I haven't watched it daily, I'm afraid.

MORE COMMENTS: page:

Please Register and login to post your comments.
» Back to News Room